Chef Niko Tests

← Articles

Leftover Turkey Sandwich With a Gravy-Soaked Middle Slice

NEW · by Chef Niko Tests

A tall leftover turkey sandwich cut in half, the gravy-soaked middle slice showing between turkey, stuffing and cranberry sauce, on a black marble counter
Illustrative image
5min read

The middle slice of bread soaks in warm gravy – that one slice keeps the whole sandwich juicy, while the two outside slices stay dry enough to hold. Make it with the turkey after Thanksgiving or Christmas dinner: three slices of bread, ½ cup of turkey, ½ cup (120 ml) of warm gravy, stuffing and cranberry sauce.

Free Holiday Dinner Game Plan →

A turkey dinner for 8, worked back from the moment you sit down. A 3-page PDF you can print.

Free. We email you the plan right away, then one email a week with new recipes and tips. Unsubscribe any time. Privacy

Ingredients

Makes 1 sandwich. Prep 10 minutes, cook about 10 minutes (warming the gravy and the stuffing).

  • 3 slices sandwich bread
  • ½ cup leftover turkey (about 4–5 slices), warmed if you like
  • ½ cup (120 ml) leftover gravy
  • ¼ cup leftover stuffing, warmed
  • ¼ cup cranberry sauce
  • 2 lettuce leaves
  • Mayonnaise, if you like
  • Salt and pepper

Method

  1. Warm the stuffing and the gravy. Warm the stuffing until it is hot all the way through. Warm the gravy in a small pan on low heat, then pour it into a shallow dish.
  2. Start the first layer. Spread the first slice with mayonnaise, if you like. Add a lettuce leaf, half the turkey and half the stuffing.
  3. Soak the middle slice. Lay the second slice in the warm gravy. Let it sit for 1 minute, flip it and let the other side soak for 1 minute.
  4. The gravy slice goes in the middle. Lift it out with a spatula and lay it on top of the stuffing.
  5. Finish the stack. Add the second lettuce leaf, the rest of the turkey, the ¼ cup cranberry sauce, the rest of the stuffing and the third slice. Season with salt and pepper as you go.
  6. Pin it and cut it. Push a toothpick through the middle, cut the sandwich in half and eat it while the middle is warm.

Chef's tip

Toast the outside, never the middle. For a crisper sandwich, butter the two outside slices and toast them in a pan on medium heat for about 2 minutes a side, until golden. The middle slice stays soft – it is there to drink the gravy.

Why it works: the chef's reasoning

One wet slice, two dry ones. Leftover turkey dries out in the fridge. Pour gravy over the whole sandwich and the bread goes soggy in your hand. Soak only the middle slice and the gravy sits right against the turkey and the stuffing, inside, where it keeps every bite juicy – while the outside slices stay dry and hold the sandwich together. It is the sandwich made famous by a TV sitcom – the gravy-soaked middle slice, the one its owner called the "Moist Maker".

Troubleshooting

  • The middle slice falls apart: the bread is too thin or it soaked too long. Use sandwich bread with some body and keep it to 1 minute a side.
  • The sandwich slides apart: press each layer down lightly as you build it, and use the toothpick.
  • Dry sandwich: the gravy was cold or too thick. Warm it on low heat; if it has set in the fridge, whisk in a splash of hot stock.
  • Soggy outside slices: gravy is dripping from the middle slice. Let the extra run off for a second before it goes in, and toast the outside slices.
  • Cold in the middle: warm the stuffing and the gravy until they are hot all the way through before you start.

Leftovers: keep them safe

The sandwich is only as good as the leftovers in it. In the US, the CDC says: refrigerate leftovers at 40°F (4°C) or colder within 2 hours of cooking, eat cooked turkey and dishes made with it within 3 to 4 days, and reheat leftovers to at least 165°F (74°C). In the UK, the Food Standards Agency says: cool cooked food and refrigerate or freeze it within one to two hours, and reheat it until it is steaming hot. Warm the turkey, the stuffing and the gravy until they are steaming hot all the way through – if you have a probe, 75°C / 167°F. More in the Thanksgiving leftovers guide.

5 questions about the leftover turkey sandwich

What is the gravy-soaked middle slice?

A third slice of bread in the middle of the sandwich, soaked in warm gravy for 1 minute a side. It keeps the sandwich juicy from the inside.

Can I use cold turkey?

Yes – the warm gravy slice and the warm stuffing take the chill off. Warm the turkey too if you like it hot.

What if I have no gravy left?

Make a quick one: 4 tbsp butter or fat, 4 tbsp flour, cook 2 minutes, then 2 cups (500 ml) hot stock a ladle at a time and simmer 5 minutes – the method is in the turkey gravy recipe.

Which bread works?

Sandwich bread with some body – white or whole wheat. Very soft, thin bread falls apart in the gravy.

Can I make it ahead?

No – build it and eat it. The middle slice should be warm. Keep the leftovers in the fridge and make the sandwich when you want it.

The rest of the table

The gravy: turkey gravy. The stuffing, in a crispy cup: crispy stuffing cups. On the side: creamy mashed potatoes (no peeling). Where the turkey comes from: spatchcock turkey, herb butter turkey crown or, for a small table, air fryer turkey breast. How long everything keeps: Thanksgiving leftovers guide.

Sources: the order of the layers from the recipe in the official cookbook of the TV series, as published by Business Insider/Yahoo; warm gravy and the 1-minute soak a side from Nutmeg Nanny (leftover Thanksgiving sandwich); toasting the outside slices from Mashed (leftover turkey sandwich recipe); leftovers – CDC (Cooking Your Holiday Turkey Safely) and the Food Standards Agency (Christmas food hygiene).