Chef Niko Tests

← Articles

Make-Ahead Thanksgiving Side Dishes – a Chef's Plan

NEW · by Chef Niko Tests

Thanksgiving side dishes prepared ahead: green bean casserole in a glass dish with a lid, parboiled potatoes in a tin and gravy in a jug
Illustrative image
3min read

Side dishes for Thanksgiving or Christmas dinner go wrong in the last hour, when everything wants the oven and the hob at once. In a professional kitchen the answer is simple: do most of it the day before and in the morning, so the last hour is only heat, carve and serve.

The day before

  • Green bean casserole. Mix the beans and the sauce, spread it in the dish, no onions on top. Cover and keep in the fridge for up to 1 day. Keep the fried onions in an airtight box at room temperature. Full method: green bean casserole from scratch.
  • Gravy. Make it with stock only and keep it in the fridge for up to 2 days. On the day you warm it and whisk in the juices from the tin. Full method: turkey gravy from the pan juices.

In the morning

  • Roast potatoes. Peel, boil 8–10 minutes in salted water, drain and leave 3 minutes to steam dry, then shake them so the edges go rough. Spread them on a tray and keep them uncovered in the fridge. They may need about 5 minutes more in the oven. Full method: crispy roast potatoes.
  • Brie bites. Assemble them in the muffin tin, cover and keep in the fridge for up to 4 hours. Bake straight from cold and add 2 minutes. Full method: brie & cranberry bites.

The last two hours (dinner at time T)

  • T−120: the casserole comes out of the fridge (30 minutes at room temperature).
  • T−90: it goes in on the lower shelf next to the crown for the crown's last 30 minutes at 180°C / 350°F (10°C lower than the recipe, so 5 minutes longer), without the onions.
  • T−60: the crown comes out, and the casserole comes out with it. Rest the crown 30–40 minutes – uncovered for the first 15, then under loose foil. Turn the oven straight up to 220°C / 425°F with the fat in the tin.
  • T−50: the potatoes go into the hot fat for 45–50 minutes, turned once.
  • T−20: carve the crown and make the gravy from the juices.
  • T−10: crispy onions on top, the casserole back in the hot oven next to the potatoes for 5 minutes.
  • T: everything on the table at the same time.

Taking a dish to a potluck?

The three mistakes

  • Everything in the last hour. The hob and the oven cannot do six jobs at once. Move every job you can to the day before.
  • Reheating in a cold oven. The oven has to be hot first – 220°C / 425°F – or the food dries out before it is hot.
  • Gravy in the last minute. It needs 20 minutes. Make it with stock the day before and only add the juices on the day.

Why it works: the chef's reasoning

A rest is not dead time. The crown has to rest 30–40 minutes anyway. That is the window for the hot oven, the potatoes and the gravy. Here is why meat needs to rest.

The habit behind a calm make-ahead plan: mise en place: the chef habit that makes a big dinner calm.

Cooking the whole meal? See the Thanksgiving dinner guide: turkey, gravy, sides and timing.